Opinion: A vanishingly rare thing has happened — we have a minister for culture who actually sounds like he's visited some of the places he has responsibility for

Our culture columnist Athena is cautiously optimistic about the future of arts, culture and architecture — even if the same old problems remain.

Castell Coch — built between 1871 and 1891 — is one of the places Chris Bryant referenced in his speech to English Heritage.
Castell Coch — built between 1871 and 1891 — is one of the places Chris Bryant referenced in his speech to English Heritage.
(Image credit: Allan Baxter / Getty)

A couple of weeks ago, Chris Bryant — the new Minister of State in the Department for Culture, Media and Sport — spoke at a reception organised by the charity English Heritage. It’s been a while since ministerial appearances of this kind could be relied on and it was a great relief — after far too many years — to hear someone with responsibility for this portfolio speaking as if they had actually visited monuments privately for pleasure.

There were references to the splendours of Castell Coch, the 1870s vineyard château raised on medieval foundations by William Burgess for the 3rd Marquess of Bute on the outskirts of Cardiff; the industrial heritage of the Rhondda Valley — the Minister’s constituency — and Lindisfarne Priory in Northumberland. He went on to speak of heritage as an endowment from the past; the monuments in the care of English Heritage, he suggested, are like an inherited silver teapot, which it is our responsibility to polish and show to advantage rather than to leave to tarnish.

There were thoughts, too, about the importance of tourism in the economy (and the potential for associated careers in the heritage sector), his dislike of aspic — both as a cooking ingredient and as a philosophy of conservation — and the enjoyment he derived from time spent in archives. By way of conclusion, the Minister hoped Sir Keir Starmer would keep him in post for a reasonable period of time.

Chris Bryant has plenty to juggle. (Photo: AFP via Getty Images)
(Image credit: AFP via Getty Images)

Athena shares that hope: the revolving door of recent years has undermined any possibility of sustained or coherent government policy. As a final and crowning mark of commitment, the Minister actually stayed for a period after his speech to talk to people. Although all this is unquestionably a welcome departure from the run-of-the-mill ministerial presentations that Athena has attended in recent years, it merely throws into relief the sheer scale of the challenges faced by the sector at the present moment.

It’s slightly ironic, for example, for the Minister to refer to the heritage of Wales given the calamitous condition of its national cultural institutions (including Cadw, which cares for the aforementioned Castell Coch). The difficulties currently faced by these bodies are in many ways representative of those confronting their counterparts across the UK. Most, inevitably, boil down to money or, rather, the lack of it; there isn’t sufficient for maintenance, modernisation or staffing (despite the fact that salaries in the sector often remain unhappily low).

The immediate future looks worrying as well. What does the darkening global situation mean for international tourism and, more immediately, what unwelcome surprises does the budget at the end of the month hold? A long-standing failing of the sector has been to plug the financial gap with its own enthusiasm. Although it’s refreshing and uplifting to see a minister share that enthusiasm, it would be catastrophic if he adopted the same approach.


The Athenaeum - Waterloo Place - London SW1. Photograph: Will Pryce/Country Life Picture Library

The Athenaeum - Waterloo Place - London SW1. Photograph: Will Pryce/Country Life Picture Library
(Image credit: Will Pryce/Country Life Picture)

The Athenaeum: Ancient history, old rivals and a recent revival for the old Carlton House haunt

One of the grandest Regency clubs in London has undergone a revival in recent years. John Goodall looks at the

Credit: Getty Images

Beware experience, lest we forget what actually makes these places important in the first place

Jousting in castles? Falconry demonstrations? That's all fine, says Athena, as long as people don't forget about the real purposes

There is a stigma attached to social housing; the expectation is that it will be poorly designed, shoddily built and in the wrong place. But it doesn't have to be that way at all.
(Image credit: Getty)

Plan properly, build well, and even the NIMBYs can't object to the solution to the housing crisis

Reforming planning and embarking on a large-scale house building plan is one of the great challenges for the new government

Inspiring progress: A picture taken on November 28, 2023 shows the wooden structure of the new spire in place at Notre-Dame de Paris Cathedral. This spire is being reconstructed to be identical to the original one, destroyed in the fire of April 15, 2019 (Photo by Ludovic MARIN / AFP).
(Image credit: AFP via Getty Images)

The re-making of Notre Dame: An extraordinary achievement by any measure

Country Life's cultural columnist Athena on the astonishing progress being made in the rebuilding of Notre-Dame de Paris — and how

Country Life

Bringing the quintessential English rural idle to life via interiors, food and drink, property and more Country Life’s travel content offers a window into the stunning scenery, imposing stately homes and quaint villages which make the UK’s countryside some of the most visited in the world.