My favourite painting: George Carter

Lamer House, Hertfordshire (Red Book proposal), 1792, by Humphry Repton (1752–1818), 7½in by 4¼in, private collection

George Carter says: When I bought Dorothy Stroud’s pioneering book on Repton, shortly after its publication in 1962, I was enthralled by his vision of the British landscape and especially impressed by the way he could cogently explain why and how his suggested improvements would work. The watercolour visuals he produced for his famous Red Books have the seductive effect of showing a scheme in its maturity, often contrasted against the unsatisfactory present state; they must have played a major part in his rapid rise to success .

George Carter is a garden designer. His new book, Setting the Scene, explores the enduring relevance of Repton’s ideas today.

John McEwen comments on Lamer House, Hertfordshire: Humphry Repton coined the term ‘landscape gardening’ to convey ‘the united powers of the landscape painter and the practical gardener’. He sold his clients a Red Book (a slim manual in red leather) illustrated with watercolours that depicted—through his invention of ‘before and after’ flaps – his proposals. His predecessors in this new art of pleasing, manmade landscapes – most famously Lancelot ‘Capability’ Brown – produced plans, rather than an amusing (complete with peppery text) and ingenious book of transformable pictures.

Repton was born in Bury St Edmunds, his father an excise collector who later had a transport business in Norwich. He attended Norwich Grammar School and, at 12, was sent to the Netherlands to learn Dutch in order to be a merchant. The young Repton found his vocation after a series of false and financially unsuccessful starts – he was 36, with a wife, four children and no fixed income, when he decided to fill the shoes of Brown, who had died in 1783.

Repton’s clients ranged from the Prince Regent to large landowners and merchants or bankers with country ‘boxes’. His client at Lamer, which was demolished after the Second World War, was C. Drake Garrard, ancestor of Apsley Cherry Garrard, author of The Worst Journey in the World (1922), about Scott’s ill-fated expedition.

Repton was very busy in the early 1790s, as he states in this Red Book. Although he worked right up until his death, many consider he was at the height of his powers in the 1790s, both as a watercolourist and as a designer who could orchestrate, by relatively simple means, great improvements to the landscape and garden setting of houses.