My favourite painting: Sholto Kynoch

The musician Sholto Kynoch picks a Caspar David Friedrich landscape.

Winter Landscape, about 1811, oil on canvas, 12¾in by 17¾in, by Caspar David Friedrich (1774–1840), National Gallery, London.
Winter Landscape, about 1811, oil on canvas, 12¾in by 17¾in, by Caspar David Friedrich (1774–1840), National Gallery, London.
(Image credit: Bridgeman Images/National Gallery, London, UK)

Sholto Kynoch on his choice, 'Winter Landscape' by Caspar David Friedrich

'I sometimes wonder if Caspar David Friedrich is a bit predictable, trite even. But then I find that, for me as a musician, his paintings resonate in the same emotional space as a Schubert song: awe and comfort, striving and reconciliation, grandiosity and intimacy, all side by side.

'The colours give such a strong sensation of winter and cold, but in a way that makes you long for it: it’s a similarly visceral experience to music. I don’t share Friedrich’s Christian faith, but the message that Nature and simplicity rule over crass mortal ambition is a powerful one.'

Sholto Kynoch is a pianist and the founder and artistic director of the Oxford International Song Festival (October 13–28).

Charlotte Mullins comments on Winter Landscape

In a snowy landscape shrouded by mist, a devoted man leans against a boulder, hands clasped in prayer. His journey has been arduous — his crutches lie abandoned in the snow. He sits on the cold ground and raises his eyes to gaze at a slender crucifix that appears to grow out of a thicket of fir trees. His eyes meet Christ’s in private communion, his piety conjuring the Gothic cathedral that rises above a distant bridge like a dawn mirage.

Completed in about 1811, this painting is believed to be one of a pair. Its contrasting companion piece hangs in the Staatliches Museum in Schwerin, Germany, a terrifying scene of two splintered dead oak trees and a decapitated wood. A man, also using a crutch, seems dwarfed by the angled trunks and blackened sky. What a contrast to Winter Landscape, with its straight, upstanding evergreen firs and soft morning light. Faith can resurrect and cure all, it seems to say. Believe in Christ and you can throw your crutches aside; turn away and a bleak, lonely future awaits.

Friedrich was at the height of his power when he finished this small painting. His large-scale works, such as Monk by the Sea, had been bought by the Crown Prince of Prussia and his religious landscapes made into altarpieces. He was at the forefront of German Romanticism, transforming the latest thinking on the sublime power of Nature into jaw-dropping visions of vast ice fields, vertiginous mountains and limitless horizons.


Bouquet of Flowers, about 1909–10, oil on canvas, 24in by 19½in, by Henri Rousseau (1844–1910), Tate, London.
(Image credit: Tate/Tate Images)

My favourite painting: Charlie McCormick

Charlie McCormick makes his choice: a Henri Rousseau classic.

Major Wilfred Thesiger, DSO, 1944, oil on canvas, 21in by 17in, by Anthony Devas (1911–58), Imperial War Museum, London.
(Image credit: IWM)

My Favourite Painting: Tahir Shah

Author and film-maker Tahir Shah chooses a military portrait.

Portrait of Lord Thomas Howard de Walden, Later 1st Earl of Suffolk, 1598, oil on canvas, 83in by 49½in, by British (English) School, English Heritage, Kenwood House, London. ©Historic England/Bridgeman Images.
(Image credit: Bridgeman Images)

My favourite painting: MOK O’Keeffe

The historian MOK O’Keeffe chooses a portrait which hangs in one of London's great houses.

Madonna and Child with Saints, Angels and Federico da Montefeltro (the Brera Altarpiece, Brera Madonna or San Bernardino Altarpiece), 1427–74, 98in by 59in, by Piero della Francesca (1415–92), Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan, Italy.
(Image credit: Bridgeman Images)

My favourite painting: Timothy Mowl

Timothy Mowl chooses The Brera Altarpiece by Piero della Francesca, a piece which he calls 'The Early Renaissance at its

Three Musicians, 1921, oil on canvas, 6ft 7in by 7ft 3¾in, by Pablo Picasso (1881–1973), Museum of Modern Art, New York, US.
(Image credit: Succession Picasso/DACS, London 2022/Bridgeman Images)

My favourite painting: Debbie Wiseman

The composer and conductor picks Three Musicians by Pablo Picasso.

Robert MacBryde, Still Life

(Image credit: Robert MacBryde, Still Life. National Galleries of Scotland. Bequeathed by Miss Elizabeth Watt 1989)

My favourite painting: Annie Sloan

The author and paint company founder loves this Cubism-inspired still life for its colour and contradiction.

Pneumatic, 1961, oil on canvas, 11¼in by Pneumatic, 1961, oil on canvas, 11¼in by 15in, by Juliet McLeod (1917–82), private collection.
(Image credit: Andrew Sydenham/Country Life)

My favourite painting: Mick Channon

The racehorse trainer Mick Channon chooses a painting of a horse.

Three Graces, 2012, by Kehinde Wiley (b. 1977), oil on canvas, 84in by 111in, private collection.
(Image credit: Kehinde Wiley. Courtesy of Roberts Projects, Los Angeles)

My favourite painting: Saad Eddine Said

Saad Eddine Said of the New Art Exchange chooses a fascinating modern painting that's full of classical influences.

No 14, 1960, 1960, oil on canvas, 114½in by 105½in, by Mark Rothko (1903–70), San Francisco Museum of Modern Art, US. 'There are no words that can adequately describe the sensation of looking at a Mark Rothko painting,' says art critic Charlotte Mullins. 'It is a transcendental experience that speaks directly to your emotions.'
(Image credit: 1998 Kate Rothko Prizel & Christopher Rothko ARS, NY and DACS, London/San Francisco Museum of Modern Art/Bridgeman Images)

My Favourite Painting: Marie Soliman

Interior designer Marie Soliman chooses an unforgettable image by Mark Rothko, one of the most distinctive modern artists of the

Jose Parla's 'Interlaced Text'.
(Image credit: Jose Parla)

My favourite painting: Joanne Ooi

EA Festival founder Joanne Ooi picks a bold image that's a mix of acrylic, ink and oil paint on canvas.

Charlotte Mullins
Contributor

Charlotte Mullins is an art critic, writer and broadcaster. Her latest book, The Art Isles: A 15,000 year story of art in the British Isles, will be published by Yale University Press in October 2025.