Curious Questions: What caused Tulipmania?
The extraordinary inflation in tulip prices in the early 17th century has gone down in history as one of humanity’s most extraordinary speculative bubbles. But was it really that simple? Anna Pavord explains what happened — and why.


Tulipmania began in the Netherlands in 1634, ended in 1637 and has puzzled historians ever since. How could one single tulip bulb have ever been sold for the equivalent of 15 years’ wages for an Amsterdam bricklayer?
The Dutch East India Company had recently been launched and this marked a period of great prosperity for the Dutch. The money to speculate was available and the tulip had an unique trick: it could change colour, seemingly at will.
The tulips that drove the mania were not ordinary ones, but flowers that, even if planted as plain purple, yellow or red, sprang up with the base colour splintered and broken — ‘feathered’ or ‘flamed’ were the terms used — in a contrasting shade.
The coveted bulbs couldn’t be produced to order, because nobody then knew how the transformation came about. That produced all the classic ingredients needed for a boom: money to spend and speculate with, plus a fashionable commodity in short supply thanks to the vagaries of nature.
What was it that made tulips break? At the time of Tulipmania, nobody knew. Some growers spread coloured paints on their tulip beds, thinking the colour would drift through the earth and soak into the bulb, but that wasn’t the answer.
The truth emerged only 300 years later, unravelled in 1927 by Dorothy Cayley, a mycologist working at the John Innes Horticultural Institute. She discovered that the ‘breaks’ that produced the tulips so prized during tulipmania were caused by a virus spread by aphids.
Why did the answer not come sooner? The word ‘virus’ wasn’t understood in the modern sense until the 1880s and the electron microscope, which enabled researchers to track the virus, did not appear until the 1920s.
Sign up for the Country Life Newsletter
Exquisite houses, the beauty of Nature, and how to get the most from your life, straight to your inbox.
Miss Cayley discovered that the effect of the virus was to partly suppress the laid-on colour of a tulip, its anthocyanin, leaving the underlying colour, always white or yellow, to show through.
The tulip is the only example of a flower made more beautiful by a disease, but the mother bulb is weakened. As a result, it produces few offsets, hence the shortage of the essential commodity traded during the time of tulipmania.
Incidentally, many of the most extreme stories that surround Tulipmania — distraught traders throwing themselves into canals and so on — have been debunked in recent years by historian Anne Goldgar, but there is no doubt that fortunes were indeed won and lost, even if many of them were mostly on paper, and the losers were generally people already wealthy enough to take the hit.
Credit: Alamy
Alan Titchmarsh: The best time of year to plant tulips
Alan Titchmars on planting tulips - and avoiding the grind of removing and storing bulbs every year.
How to grow tulips, by the gardener who creates the incomparable display at Parham Park
Parham Park’s head gardener Tom Brown shares his tips on how to grow tulips.
Credit: John Glover / Alamy Stock Photo
Ten simply magnificent photographs of Pashley Manor, Britain's greatest tulip festival
Every year, Pashley Manor's stunning tulip festival attracts people from across the world to enjoy these beautiful blooms in a
Country Life is unlike any other magazine: the only glossy weekly on the newsstand and the only magazine that has been guest-edited by HRH The King not once, but twice. It is a celebration of modern rural life and all its diverse joys and pleasures — that was first published in Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee year. Our eclectic mixture of witty and informative content — from the most up-to-date property news and commentary and a coveted glimpse inside some of the UK's best houses and gardens, to gardening, the arts and interior design, written by experts in their field — still cannot be found in print or online, anywhere else.
-
The fate of the last wolf in Britain? Country Life Quiz of the Day
Our daily quiz tests your gut instinct, powers of deduction and downright luck. Unless you happen to know all the answers for sure.
By Toby Keel Published
-
How to make an ethereal-sounding seafood, spinach and asparagus puff-pastry cloud
Our Kitchen Garden Cook's recipe for a stuffed puff-pastry cloud is easier to make than it is to say.
By Melanie Johnson Published
-
Curious Questions: How did the Leyland Cypress go from botanical accident to taking over the world?
The near-ubiquitous Leyland Cypress — or leylandii — is an evergreen with an extraordinary back story. Martin Fone explains.
By Martin Fone Published
-
Curious Questions: Why do leaves change colour in Autumn? And why do some go yellow while others are red, purple or brown?
The riotous colours on the trees around us are one of the highlights of the year — but why do leaves change colour in Autuumn? Mark Griffiths explains.
By Mark Griffiths Published
-
Curious Questions: What is a garden hermit?
Martin Fone takes a look at the curious history of the hermits who spent years living happily in the grounds of country houses, perhaps the ultimate garden folly.
By Martin Fone Published
-
Curious Questions: Will the aspidistra ever fly again?
The aspidistra was once the most popular of all houseplants in Britain, but these days they're barely seen. Why did that happen, asks Martin Fone, and can it make a comeback?
By Martin Fone Published
-
Curious Questions: How did garden gnomes take over the world — and even The Queen's private garden?
Vertically challenged, bearded and rosy-cheeked, cheerful gnomes might make for unlikely cover stars, but — says Ben Lerwill — they’ve long graced books, album covers and even The Queen’s private garden.
By Ben Lerwill Published
-
Curious Questions: How do you tell the difference between a British bluebell and a Spanish bluebell?
Martin Fone delves into the beautiful bluebell, one of the great sights of Spring.
By Martin Fone Published
-
Curious Questions: What's the difference between a labyrinth and a maze?
You may never have thought to ponder what distinguishes a labyrinth from a maze. But as Martin Fone explains, it's something of a minefield.
By Martin Fone Published
-
Curious Questions: Which came first — the plastic flower pot or the garden centre?
Martin Fone takes a look at the curiously intriguing tale of the evolution of nurseries in Britain.
By Martin Fone Published