Athena: Perhaps the time has come to be more honest about the importance of beauty

When it comes to buildings of historical and architectural note, we don't love them simply because they are old, but because they are beautiful and engage our attention.

Salisbury Cathedral: One of Britain's most beautiful buildings.
Salisbury Cathedral: One of Britain's most beautiful buildings.
(Image credit: Julian Elliott)

The idea of historic buildings as documents of history is not new. Indeed, it was voiced more than a century ago by Lord Curzon, when he spoke in 1913 in support of the Ancient Monuments Act in Parliament. ‘We regard the national monuments to which this Bill refers,’ he said, ‘as part of the heritage and history of the nation. They are part of the heritage of the nation, because every citizen feels an interest in them although he may not own them; and they are part of the history of the nation, because they are documents just as valuable in reading the records of the past as is any manuscript or parchment deed…’

There are limits to what you can read in the form of a building — not least because words convey ideas more articulately than bricks and mortar — but Lord Curzon was not wrong. The physical fabric of monuments has its own story to tell and the skill of deciphering that is central to the work of archaeologists and architectural historians. One of their chief aims when attempting to understand a particular site is to explain who built what when and to assign each stage in its evolution — as far as is possible — to a particular religious, social or political context.

‘We don’t love things because they are old, but because they are beautiful and engage our attention’

This approach, however, does come with an accompanying challenge. The things it naturally emphasises — dates, technical detail and historic personalities; what largely constitutes the ‘significance’ of a monument in modern parlance — are not really at the root of what attracts most of us to the vestiges of the past. Indeed, in Athena’s experience, we don’t come to love things because they are old, but because they are beautiful and engage our attention. It’s only when that interest is awakened that we want to know about their history.

Even then, our appetite for historical detail can be surprisingly limited. As an added complication, association with certain historical narratives can put people off the past. It’s an experience comparable to having the enjoyment of a novel or a piece of music destroyed by knowing too much about its creator. Despite these realities, when heritage professionals advocate sites to the public, they tend to give greatest emphasis to their historical associations.

That approach partly reflects our collective nervousness about beauty. Think back to the Deputy Prime Minister last year striking the word out of planning legislation on the grounds that no one could agree what it was (although it’s surely a quality worth aspiring for in new buildings and does unquestionably exist, even if we all see it differently). Yet talking about beauty came naturally to Romantics and the admirers of the Picturesque and it is unquestionably their sensibilities that fundamentally inform our enjoyment of the past. Perhaps the time has come to be more honest about the importance of beauty and — for all the difficulty of defining it — celebrate it more.

Athena is Country Life’s Cultural Crusader. She writes a column every week.

Country Life

Country Life is unlike any other magazine: the only glossy weekly on the newsstand and the only magazine that has been guest-edited by HRH The King not once, but twice. It is a celebration of modern rural life and all its diverse joys and pleasures — that was first published in Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee year. Our eclectic mixture of witty and informative content — from the most up-to-date property news and commentary and a coveted glimpse inside some of the UK's best houses and gardens, to gardening, the arts and interior design, written by experts in their field — still cannot be found in print or online, anywhere else.

Read more
The Garden Hall at Pitshill House
The Country Life Top 100 2025: A triumph of timelessness, substance and longevity over throwaway style
Aldourie Castle
The ideal of the Scottish castle: Aldourie's joyful fantasy of turrets, invention and recreation
A view of the Venetian Room at Wolterton Hall.
Country Life's top 10 architecture stories of 2024, from the palace that's 'the stuff of dreams' to a Palladian masterpiece you can rent by the weekend
Black and white image of a life drawing class
Why it’s imperative that schoolchildren have access to art and design classes
Athenian Legacy property pictures
This elegant Greek villa offers would-be buyers a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to live in the shadow of the Acropolis
Van Gogh's bedroom on the cover of Country Life
Country Life 12 February 2025
Latest in Comment & Opinion
Black and white image of a life drawing class
Why it’s imperative that schoolchildren have access to art and design classes
The dance more complex than the most elaborate mating ritual: Or, how to buy a new car
noGf4zJCcG4LEnCDjGmSmV.jpg
Opinion: The countryside is too loud
hoq3B7DyUrJgxLpCKRRijV.jpg
Joe Gibbs: 'There are many reasons why a chap might be found crawling across the floor of his London club of an evening. In my case, I was in search of a digital hearing aid'
Salisbury Cathedral: One of Britain's most beautiful buildings.
Athena: Perhaps the time has come to be more honest about the importance of beauty
RcaAQqDqGbgLKCQUUk2YYa.jpg
Minette Batters: 'I naively believed we could help teach our fellow African farmers how to farm. How wrong I’ve been; we have so much to learn from them'
Latest in Features
Diamond brooch
How Cartier became ‘the jeweller of kings and the king of jewellers’
A villa in Rome on the Via Nomentana
A historic villa for sale on the Via Nomentana worthy of Rome's rich history
dogs on Country Life 26 March 2025
Country Life 26 March 2025
Jade tiled bathroom
A tub carved from a single block of San Marino marble — and nine more beautiful things for the ultimate bathroom
Images of Edwardian Ashton House, near Chard
Eight bedrooms of unlisted Edwardian elegance with sweeping views of Somerset
Iron Age artefacts
Archaeologists in North Yorkshire discover ‘the biggest and most important Iron Age hoard ever found in Britain’